It has been over seven months since the U.S. Department of Labor formally issued a proposed rule under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) setting forth this current administration’s standards for determining whether workers are independent contractors (ICs) or employees under that federal law. The rule, once issued in final form, is intended to replace the Biden administration’s 2024 rule on IC status under the FLSA, which had sought to replace the Trump administration’s 2021 rule on IC status. According to informed reports, a final 2026 rule will be issued sometime this month. Based on the minor differences between the proposed and final rules under the first Trump administration, we expect the final IC rule by this administration will likewise be nearly identical to the proposed rule. Like the 2021 rule, the final rule when issued will undoubtedly be regarded as business-friendly. That will give some comfort to businesses and be viewed by many as favoring the increased use of ICs throughout the U.S. While issuance of the final rule may change the commentary, the law has not changed in the least. The Labor Department’s rule on IC status is merely a regulation and not the law. Only Congress can change the law. Further, the courts, not the Labor Department, are the final arbiters of IC status under the FLSA. No court has relied on either the 2021 or the 2024 IC rule, and it is likely that few if any courts will rely on the new IC rule once finalized. Instead, the courts have historically chosen to apply their own judicial precedent rather than give deference to these administrative rules on IC status. The Labor Department’s anticipated issuance of a final IC rule will, however, likely result in more visibility on the issue of IC misclassification; that, in turn, may well cause plaintiffs’ class action lawyers to bring even more misclassification lawsuits, particularly under state IC laws. For this reason, savvy businesses would be well-advised to enhance their compliance with IC laws, especially state laws governing ICs, by using a process such as IC Diagnostics®, as described in our Takeaways below.

Continue Reading The Final Independent Contractor Rule Will Only Change the Conversation, Not the Law

Today, less than 24 hours before the end of the Trump Administration, the Labor Department issued an opinion letter that distributors who resell to retail outlets food products they purchase from two or more unnamed food manufacturers can be lawfully classified as independent contractors under the federal wage and hour law. Distributors of food products have brought a number of class and collective actions against food manufacturers over the past few years, as reported in this blog. One large food manufacturer paid over $47 million in settlements of collective and class action lawsuits brought by distributors alleging independent contractor misclassification. While this last-minute opinion letter may be useful to companies defending these types of cases, savvy food manufacturers that have chosen to elevate their level of compliance with federal and state IC laws through the use of a process such as IC Diagnostics (TM) shouldn’t need to rely on this administrative action to successfully establish the IC status of their independent distributors.
Continue Reading Labor Department’s Last Opinion Letter: Distributors of Food Products are Independent Contractors