We expected the U.S. Department of Labor’s final rule on independent contractor (IC) status under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) would be nearly identical to the proposed rule issued earlier this year. The final IC rule was issued today, and it is as we expected: it is virtually the same – with only three new sentences and a few additional examples of how the rule will be applied. Many media outlets are likely to characterize the final rule as business-friendly and supportive of the use of ICs throughout the U.S. That may give comfort to businesses. But, as we note below, the Trump administration’s final IC rule on the status of workers as ICs or employees under the FLSA is unlikely to be given deference by the courts, which have historically chosen to apply their own judicial precedent rather than give deference to administrative rules on IC status that change back and forth when a new administration enters the White House. Further, most IC misclassification lawsuits as well as agency investigations and proceedings are not brought only under the FLSA but rather are commenced in whole or in part under state laws, most of which use different tests for IC status. While some businesses may read the next few days’ headlines and feel as though their level of IC compliance is sufficient, prudent businesses are not likely to stand pat with their level of IC compliance. Rather, savvy companies will use the issuance of a final federal IC rule as a prompt to enhance their compliance with all applicable IC laws, especially state laws governing ICs, by using a process such as IC Diagnostics®, as we discuss in our Takeaways below.
Analysis
The final IC rule issued today, November 19, 2026, starts out by rescinding all conflicting and inconsistent administrative rulings, interpretations, practices, and enforcement policies of the Labor Department relating to the classification of ICs and employees. This is designed to override the Biden administration’s 2024 rule on IC status.
In determining IC status, the final regulation, as did the proposed regulation, lists five (5) factors to be examined, but it states that the five factors “are not exhaustive, and no single factor is dispositive.” The rule also notes that any factor related to the relationship between an individual and potential employer may be relevant. This approach is consistent with judicial decisions under the FLSA where the courts have considered dozens of factors bearing on IC status, and the final regulation therefore validates this type of broad judicial inquiry.
As did the proposed rule, the Labor Department’s final IC regulation refers to two of the specified five factors as “core factors”:
(1) the nature and degree of the individual’s control over their work; and
(2) the individual’s opportunity for profit or loss.
The final rule states that these two core factors “are the most probative as to whether or not an individual is an economically dependent ‘employee,’ … and each is therefore typically carries greater weight in the analysis than any other factor.” While the final rule does not create a legal presumption, it does state that if both core factors point toward the same classification, whether employee or IC, “there is a substantial likelihood that is the individual’s accurate classification.”
This conclusion is not a new way to analyze IC status under the FLSA. Rather, it is consistent with current jurisprudence. As the Department of Labor stated in its lengthy supplementary material appearing before the final rule, “whenever the control and opportunity factors both pointed to the same classification – whether employee or independent contractor – that was the court’s conclusion regarding the worker’s ultimate classification.” Final Rule at page 111 (just after note 204).
Under the first factor relating to control, the final rule restates many of the same conclusions that most courts have already articulated – that several types of activities do “not constitute [the type of] control that makes the individual more or less likely to be an employee under the Act.” See Final Rule at 136 [just before note 225]. According to the final rule, those types of actions that are not legally meaningful include requiring an individual to:
- comply with specific legal obligations;
- satisfy health and safety standards;
- carry insurance;
- meet contractually agreed-upon deadlines or quality control standards; or
- satisfy other similar terms that are typical of contractual relationships between businesses (as opposed to employment relationships).
The final regulation, though, considerably overstates the law when it says that controlling an individual’s schedule or workload by “directly or indirectly” requiring the individual to work exclusively for one company, weighs in favor of the individual being an employee under the FLSA. Many legitimate ICs commit to one or more projects or other arrangements that require a concentrated, full-time undertaking to produce deliverables within a tight timeframe, indirectly foreclosing their work for other clients. That is not the type of control that should generally support employee status. A legitimate IC choosing to provide services on a full-time basis to another business is hardly indicative of employee status. The final rule in this respect is not logical or employer-friendly.
The final rule next addresses the “core factor” of profit or loss. Some courts in the past have examined only the worker’s financial investment. The final regulation, however, would follow newer court decisions that also have examined the manner in which profits are maximized by the individual’s initiative.
The final regulation also addresses the three so-called “other” factors: (1) the amount of skill required for the work; (2) the degree of permanence of the working relationship; and (3) whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production. The first two of these “other” factors are business unfriendly.
Regarding workers’ skills, the rule fails to take into account that many legitimate ICs do not have what some may refer to as an elevated skillset. For example, some may think that taxi drivers do not have a high degree of skill, yet a number are not only very skillful but also operate their own taxi business, which has led a number of courts to conclude that taxi drivers can indeed be legitimate ICs. On the other hand, a doctor working for a hospital plainly has elevated skills, but that does not make them an IC if the health care institution directs and controls their work and pays them a fixed salary. Thus, this factor of “skill” should look not only at educational skills but also business skills regardless of education, and should not be used to tip the balance in a close case where the worker’s occupational and business skills are not those that most members of the general public also possess.
The final rule’s treatment of the degree of permanence factor fails to recognize that many legitimate IC relationships are permanent or at least semi-permanent by choice of the worker – for example, a gardener who provides service weekly to a homeowner for 20 years; a distributor who chooses to operate their own business by exclusively distributing one company’s products over a prolonged period of time; and a tutor who provides frequent tutoring to the same family’s children throughout their junior and senior high school years. These types of circumstances dealing with permanence should have been recognized in the final rule.
The third and last “other” factor is whether the work “is part of an integrated unit of production.” As the final rule states: “This factor is different from the concept of the importance or centrality of the individual’s work to the potential employer’s business.” In this manner, the Department of Labor is seeking to change the focus of this factor, which historically has been given little weight by the courts anyway.
The proposed regulation includes a subsection with 14 examples of worker arrangements in different industries, along with comments on whether those workers would be properly classified as employees or ICs under the final regulation. Because ICs are commonplace in hundreds of business sectors, these examples are not meaningful to most stakeholders; indeed, the final rule states that the illustrations “are limited to substantially similar factual situations.”
Lastly, the final regulation addresses the “primacy of actual practice.” It states that a company’s actual practice is more significant than what is written in a purported IC’s contract. This is consistent with decades of court decisions on this point.
Takeaways
Like the IC rules issued by both the first Trump administration in 2021 and the Biden administration in 2024, the final IC rule is likely to face lawsuits regarding its enforceability. But such litigation challenging the 2026 final rule will likely have limited practical significance. No court has ever relied on either the 2021 or 2024 rules in determining the IC status of workers, and it is equally unlikely that the courts will rely on the 2026 rule.
In addition, the Labor Department’s final rule under the FLSA has no application to the IC status of workers under most other federal laws, such as ERISA and the National Labor Relations Act, which have different worker classification tests. The final rule also has no application to the classification of workers under state IC tests, most of which vary considerably from the test for IC status under the FLSA. In that regard, most litigation against companies alleging IC misclassification arises in whole or in part under state laws and not exclusively under the federal FLSA. For the past 15 years, plaintiffs’ class action attorneys have continued to focus on companies that are out of compliance with federal and/or state IC laws. Because the Trump administration’s final IC rule will be construed by many as favoring IC status, it may well prompt more class action lawsuits by plaintiffs’ attorneys under state IC laws. Thus, rather than taking comfort by the issuance of the final federal IC rule under the FLSA, businesses should wisely seek to evaluate and enhance their compliance with all applicable IC laws. Some companies have resorted to a process such as IC Diagnostics® to elevate their level of compliance with IC laws governing their operations. As noted in prior blog posts, companies seeking to enhance their compliance in this area of the law can use this process to restructure, re-document, and re-implement their IC relationships, consistent with their business model, in a customized and sustainable manner that minimizes their risks of IC misclassification liability under federal and state laws.
Written by Richard Reibstein, Publisher
Compiled and edited by Janet Barsky, Managing Editor